
Walk into any gym and you will see tubs of protein powder. Many young people ask me, “Doctor, do I need it to build muscle?” Let us look at the facts calmly.
What the national guidelines say
The Dietary Guidelines for Indians 2024 from ICMR-NIN advise that people should try to meet protein needs from natural food, and caution against long-term use of large amounts of protein powder or concentrates, because of possible risks such as bone mineral loss and kidney strain. They also note that extra protein beyond about 1.6 g/kg per day does not give additional muscle gain with training.
What other experts say
Some doctors point out that whey is a natural milk protein, and that supplements from reputable, tested brands can be useful for athletes or people who truly cannot meet their needs. The point on which most agree is that food comes first and supplements are only a back-up.
Who may need extra protein help
- Older adults with poor appetite.
- People recovering from illness or surgery.
- Strict vegetarians who cannot get enough from food.
- Athletes with very high needs, under guidance.
If you choose to use one
- Talk to your doctor first, especially if you have kidney, liver or heart disease or diabetes.
- Pick a brand with third-party testing, and a clear label.
- Avoid those with added sugar, flavours and long ingredient lists.
- Use it to fill the gap, not to replace meals.
- Drink enough water.
Cheaper and better
Eggs, milk, curd, paneer, dal, soya, sprouts, fish and chicken provide protein with other nutrients, at a lower cost. A glass of milk and two eggs give about 20 grams of protein.
Beware of claims
Products that promise “instant muscle” or “fat burning” are not reliable. Steroid or hidden drug contamination has been found in some supplements around the world. Buy from reputed shops.
If you live in Gopanpally, Gowlidoddi, Nallagandla or Tellapur, or work in the Financial District or Nanakramguda, you can get simple, practical food guidance at our clinic in Gachibowli. Contact us to book a visit.
Keep reading
Your family doctor,
Akhila Reddy
MBBS, DNB (Family Medicine) | TSMC Reg. No. APMC/FMR/74261
AMC Hospital, Gopanpally, Gachibowli, Hyderabad
This article is for general health education and does not replace a check-up. Every person is different, so please speak to your doctor before changing any medicine. In an emergency, call 108 or go to the nearest hospital.
References
- ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition. Dietary Guidelines for Indians 2024. https://www.nin.res.in
- Deccan Herald. Limit salt & sugar; avoid ultra-processed foods & protein supplements: ICMR new nutrition guidelines (10 May 2024). https://www.deccanherald.com
- Morton RW et al. A systematic review, meta-analysis and meta-regression of the effect of protein supplementation on resistance training-induced gains in muscle mass and strength. Br J Sports Med 2018;52(6):376-384.